"The Soapbox", Wine Biz

Re-Imagining Sherry:How the Ancient Fortified Wine Can Rebrand

Written by Simone Popov · 7 min read >

Spain is all the rage these days.

Truly, there hasn’t been a better time to get into Spanish wine. With old school wine regions like Rioja and Priorat redefining themselves while keeping with the high level of quality they set, and new upstarts in places like Sierra de Gredos, the Basque Country, and Galicia taking over and bringing those great vibes and fantastic (sometimes atypical) wines, Spanish wine lovers are not starved for choice.  Not to mention Sparkling wine, where Penedès is seeing a great quality renaissance, with many producers ditching the “Cava” moniker in favor of a more free-form, quality-focused approach.

However, some regions are lagging.

In fact, one of the most iconic wines of Spain, one of its oldest calling cards on the international stage, whose praises have been sung by literary mavens like William Shakespeare, Edgar Allan Poe, Charles Dickens, and more, is on the decline.

I am, of course, talking about Sherry. 

Table of Contents

    During a visit to Andalucia, I got to go to Bodegas Yuste, one of the region’s premier Sherry houses, and experience one of the oldest Soleras in the world for myself. So, drawing on that experience and my personal wine knowledge, I would like to hypothesize about Sherry: why is it losing traction in the market? How is it viewed by consumers? And what can be done to reinvigorate the image of this truly singular style of wine?

    A Bit of History

    Sherry was first mentioned in the 1st Century BC by the Greek geographer Strabo, who noted that the vines were brought to Jerez by the Phoenicians.  The Phoenicians gave the name to the land “Xera”, and exported the first Xera wines all across the Mediterranean.

     The Romans built roads that connected their vast empire; those roads carried “Vinum Cerensis” to high acclaim in various Roman provinces.

    In 711 AD, the Moors conquered the South, and though wine was outlawed, “Sherish” remained as an area producing grapes for perfume and luxury food of the Caliphates.

    After the “Reconquista” , the wine continued to flow and soon, around the 12th Century, the wines still known as “Sherish” found their way across the channel to Britain, where it became a mainstay of authors and royals alike.

     As the Spaniards looked to new frontiers in the West, the well-traveled Sherry joined them on their excursions and soon found a new home in the colonies, finding its way on the ships of Magellan and Christopher Columbus. 

    In the second half of the 18th century, the producers of Jerez devised the ingenious method of “fractional blending” called “Solera”, a method where wine from various age “tiers” gets blended across so that the final product pulled is the most complex and balanced wine possible (see image below for further explanation)

    A chart for Vinos Generosos, dry wines that are gaining more relevance in the market for Sherry.

    What Could Go Wrong

    To answer that question, we need to look at the Sherry decline. And for that, some data is helpful. A graph based on the official reports of the Consejo Regulador de Jerez shows a notable decline, from 150 million liters to just over 30 million in less than 30 years, signaling an 80% drop (Sherrynotes). This data, however, highlights Sherry as a single category, which doesn’t account for specific sectors of Sherry that may be seeing success in the market but lumps them together with a variety of other products that are also “Sherry” and are not just struggling but in a state of freefall without a parachute.

    Data from an article written in 2014, updated to include up to 2021

    What Is Sherry?

    If some Sherries are doing well, why isn’t all Sherry doing well? Well, for one, the term “Sherry” encompasses a wide variety of styles, many of which differ markedly from one another. Our first divide is the “dry” vs “sweet” segmentation, where dry Sherries (official terminology: “Vinos Generosos) like Fino and Amontillado are sweetened to become “Pale Cream” and “Medium” (official terminology: ”Vinos Generosos de Licor”) But although Pale Cream might be just a sweetened Fino, the addition of sugar makes for philosophically different wines, immediately altering character, mouthfeel, and perception.

     The second divide is in the dry Sherry category, where the wines can be aged oxidatively (Oloroso), Biologically under a veil of yeast (Fino, Manzanilla), or both (Amontillado, Palo Cortado). Taking the two extremes here, Fino and Olorso Sherry, are both “Sherry”. But they are not alike.

     There are also naturally sweet Sherry wines (official terminology: “Vinos Dulces Naturales”), made from Pedro Ximenez and Moscatel grapes. These are not sweetened dry wines, but rather sweet wines from distinct grapes.

    Read More about the Sherry Styles and Classification on the official DO website.

    With so much distinction, should we even lump these styles together under one name? Perhaps this is the first hurdle to perceiving the style as a product.

    History and Diversity: a source of antipathy?

    I have noted the region of “Jerez” and its storied history. I have also noted the diversity of styles that come from this area. Neither aspect is necessarily negative, but in Sherry’s case, both are skewed and can detract from the drink’s reputation. For one, the wide variety of styles can confuse the customer, who may then associate the style they had with Sherry and never want to try the product again. The customer is fickle, and one bad experience can lose them.

    Perhaps history is a more important issue.  Sherry’s association with antiquity can lead consumers to view the product negatively, associating it with wines that “their grandfather would drink “rather than something modern and trendy.

    So, in my hypothetical, Sherry is confusing and antiquated, but what else can be gleaned from Sherry’s perception?  For one, Sherry is simply cheap.

    The Affordability Dilemma

    Even exported Sherry can sometimes be sold at $10-15 stateside. Jerez is a region of “Houses”. These companies purchase grapes in large quantities and use the Solera system, which allows them to leverage economies of scale. With just a couple of the big guys able to drive prices down so low, the challenge for others is to match those prices. This practice makes Sherry dirt-cheap, which may be positive for very price-sensitive markets. Yet in a Premiumization-driven environment, the devaluation of one brand can lead to the devaluation of the entire category.

    Contra-Low-Alc Trend

    It certainly doesn’t help that, on top of the issues above, Sherry is fortified. The product’s high alcohol content goes against the trend of healthy living and low alcohol options.

    Sherry, a Shift in Perception

    Perhaps I painted a somewhat gloomy view of Sherry as a product. And I can concede that trends are cyclical, and what is up today can go down tomorrow. But the outlook hasn’t been positive, even for the most optimistic of spectators.

    Does Sherry need to change to keep up with the times? A “New Sherry,” perhaps? Or do we, the consumers, just want a rebrand?

    I don’t think Sherry needs to change because it has always been a high-quality wine (even the really affordable wines). But a rebrand isn’t a bad idea. The antiquity association is not ideal, but the wine is ancient, and there is a lot to say about its history and status. And yes, Sherry is confusing, but so is Burgundy, and so is, for that matter, Champagne. If positioned well, Sherry will appeal to the right audience for its complexity and history.

    Fixing Sherry: Ideas

    So what can producers do to improve Jerez’s perception on the market?

    Of course, I have a few opinions on the matter.

    1. Look to Champagne

    Champagne is the perfect example of how a region known for large commercial houses and blending across vintages became enormously popular. And though Champagne and Sherry are very different products, both focus on style rather than location, and both are quite complicated and diverse. If Jerez is to market its premium wines, it needs to tailor its approach, as the Champenois do.

    2. Look to Premiumization

    People are drinking less and enjoying more. This is generally a good thing, unless you are a producer of mass-market garbage, in which case you might be in trouble. With Sherry, one needs to train the market to accept that a fortified wine from Jerez can cost 20, 40, or even 60 dollars. It may be difficult, but I believe it is possible. Sherry, with its unique flavor profile and incredible complexity, is indeed a wine to be savored over time.

    3. Look to Food/Culture

    Andalucia is one of the most beautiful, striking, culturally complex regions in the world. The Spanish, Muslim, and African cultures meld seamlessly there, creating a vibrant tapestry of food, music, art, dance, and architecture. To help “preimmunize” Sherry, one can look to the region where the product is made. Especially, we can look at the cuisine. Sherry is truly a food-focused wine, one that can serve as a seasoning for a dish as much as it can accompany it as a beverage. Many Tapas bars already offer Sherry flights, but there’s even more that can be done to highlight just how well a Fino can pair with Manchego cheese, a couple of Gildas, or the world-famous Jamón Iberico.

    When you taste these pairings, you realize that no other wine can come close.

    4. Look at Alternatives (in consumption)

    The wine purist will undoubtedly want to crucify me for this, but I am a firm believer that Sherry can go very well in a cocktail. This is not a devaluation of a product (especially if the cocktail costs $20), but rather a way to adapt, improve perception, and put one foot in the modern world. If a Sherry-based cocktail is cool, that means Sherry is cool. And if a $10 bottle of Sherry can be used to make a $20 cocktail, and kept on the shelf for a whole week, well, that is fantastic for the bar/restaurant owner.

    5. Sherry Health

    I’m not going to say something stupid like “they should make low alcohol Sherry” , for one, because it is impossible without stripping Sherry of its identity. But, as with the previous point, Sherry has a longer shelf life due to its winemaking method, and can also be incorporated into cocktails and mixed drinks.

    One of my favorite “hacks” to drink Sherry and be healthy is to mix Fino/Manzanilla with club soda and a twist of lemon. I get all the flavor of the Sherry, a little dialed down, and with fresh, zesty character of the peel as well. I dilute the Sherry, creating something low-alcohol and delicious. Alternatively, you may have an open bottle of Oloroso in your cellar and drink an ounce every couple of days like whiskey. You don’t have to finish a bottle over 2-3 days, as you would with a non-fortified still wine.

    Isn’t “moderation” a solution to living a healthy life?

    Aside: Vino De Pasto

    Many producers in Jerez are branching out and producing “Vino de Pasto”, a still unfortified style of wine using ancient and modern grapes to make something incredibly distinct while still paying homage to the ancient styles of Sherry. This is an incredibly important style for the future of Andaluz wines, but not applicable to the Sherry discussion in my view. Vino de Pasto and Sherry are two distinct products, and while it is good to diversify, fixing the “Sherry Problem” without completely abandoning the product will require us to focus specifically on the fortified, blended style.  

    Conclusion

    “Can Sherry be cool again?” is a question posed by many a blogger and wine writer.

    If you talk to a wine nerd, especially one interested in Spanish wine, Sherry is super cool. Did you know Albariza, the soil of Jerez, is 25% more calcareous than that of Côte de Blanc in Champagne???? Did you!?

    But I digress…

    Maybe Sherry hasn’t been ubiquitously cool since the days of William Shakespeare, and those days are long gone. And perhaps some of the predispositions are still a bit too difficult to overcome. But in a few places, some as close to me as San Francisco, and others as far as London England, a small craft quality resurgence is happening by bars who, utilizing some or all of the ideas presented above, are positioning themselves and the Sherry they sell as a truly exceptional product, capable of high levels of quality, perfect pairings, and enjoyment as much as any other wine.

    Because Sherry is an exceptional product, the positioning will come with it.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *