"The Soapbox", Wine Biz

The Plight of the Wine Importer [A Dispatch Soliloquy]

Written by Simone Popov · 5 min read >

It’s a tough time to be a Wine Importer right now.

A few days ago, an orange-colored, baby-handed convicted felon, failed businessman, and misogynist– who also happens to be one of the most influential people on earth– went on his buddy’s propaganda platform and declared war on the wine industry. He then claimed that his 200% tariffs on E.U. imported wines will be “great” for the U.S. Wine and Champagne businesses. Regarding the U.S. wine industry, the statement is just false, and U.S. “Champagne” is not a real industry, no matter how much shit bubbles his namesake winery produces. His words soon disseminated through the world of wine, drawing anger, frustration, and confusion from everyone with even the most minute understanding of the U.S. wine trade. 

Undoubtedly, this retaliatory, short-sighted tactic will do irreparable damage to all businesses across the three-tier distribution chain. In the end, it will be the American consumer who will foot the bill of this international “dick-measuring contest.”

But I Digress…

I have never intended Dispatch as a political platform, and have kept opinions to myself. Furthermore, many articles, posts, and videos have explained the ramifications of a 200% tariff hike on all wine businesses, many do so with the sang-froid that this writer does not possess [such as this one by Isaac Asimov].

Instead, we would like to examine the role of wine importer, a profession close to our heart and most under threat from these looming sanctions.

The Role of the Importer

On the surface, a U.S.-based wine importer’s main objective is to bring International wine to the country. But let’s look at this with a bit of a magnifying glass. The first step of the importer process is an agreement between the producer [in this case, a foreign-based winery] and the importer. At this point, the importer selects the wines he wants to import and takes full responsibility for the inventory. This exchange is also the last point at involving the foreign-based winery directly.

Following the wines’ acquisition and transport to a consolidation warehouse, which the importer selects and pays for, it is time for the wine to set out on the voyage. The process may take 6-9 months, depending on many international logistical factors. The importer is now responsible for filing the necessary paperwork with the TTB (Tax and Trade Bureau), including a COLA (Certificate of Label Approval/Exemption), which the importer must submit for the wine to clear customs. The wine would arrive at a designated bonded warehouse, where the taxes and fees will be deferred until the wine is ready for sale.

Finally, after months of stress, hope, prayer, filling out forms, exchanging jabs with the TTB, and essentially operating at a loss (if this is the first time a company imports wine), the business is finally able to start making money.

The Importer and The U.S. Market

The point when the wine is available for sale in the U.S. market is any importer’s make or break point. You have spoken to producers, tasted the wines, and undergone a tedious and complex importing process. Now, it is the litmus test of whether your choices of wines will pay off in your market.

The U.S. industry operates on a three-tier system where:

A Supplier (A Winery or Importer) sells wine to a Wholesaler/Distributor, who then sells the wine to a Retailer/Restaurant, and then finally, the consumer may purchase the product. At each step, the wine changes hands, growing in price so that each business acquiring the wine can profit.

 Each state’s market is different, and how you sell your wine will differ depending on your location. California is an open market that permits the importer to be the retailer and wholesaler so that you can control your sales via Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) sales or selling to other businesses (Restaurants/Wine Shops/Wine Bars/ etc). Many states do not provide such freedom, and an importer is locked into selling their wine to a separate distributor entity.

From a consumer’s perspective, the more the wine exchanges hands, the more pricey the wine becomes.

From an importer’s perspective, the question is about control or longevity. One may opt to have complete control of their sales (if permitted by the state), thus influencing the brand’s perception in the market and the profit margin of the wine. This option is more desirable but costly, not just in expenditure (sales reps/ lunches/ DTC  logistics are not free) but also in effort. Otherwise, an importer can choose to sell to a distributor (or is forced to in some states), making a smaller profit and relying more on another entity to represent their brand in the market.

 Control and Marketing

I’ve used the term “control” in the previous chapter to indicate how much influence the importer has on its brand. If an importer sells a wine to a distributor with 200 other products, 10 of which are similar in style/region/price point, there is a real risk of the wine getting “lost in the mix” and its sales declining. If a distributor sees that your product is not moving, you risk losing the partnership, and your bottom line will suffer.

 Thus, one can’t just say, “Well, I sold my product to this distributor, so now I can just close my eyes and not think about it because I already made a profit.”

The importer will need to promote their products by attending events, lobbying for scores and journal entries, posting on social media/running digital advertising,  hosting dinners and educational seminars, seeking distributor partnerships in other states, and ultimately persuading both the consumer and the trade to buy more of their product.

This is when the importer must ask some important questions, such as;

  1. Does your product/product mix offer something unique/new/attractive in the market? Can you communicate your difference well enough to convince the people you are selling to?
  2. Is your niche/ target customer effective and willing to continue to buy your wines?
  3. Is the consumer/ distributor/ retailer willing to pay the price for your wines? (after all the margins and fees paid)
  4. Can you generate enough demand to sell through your product? And if you can, can you fulfill all the orders necessary with the quantity of the wines you currently have? (remember, the process of importing more wine takes 6-9 months, so you may have to project and see the future)

None of these questions are easy to answer, and an importer will undoubtedly face more decisive inquiries into their viability.

The Importer’s Motivation

The importer’s job is challenging, laborious, thankless, and (apart from a few outliers) not too profitable. After all the overhead and importing costs, an importer may see that even the highest, most ideal markups on their products are not enough to constitute a thriving, profitable business model

So why would someone take on such high risk for a relatively low reward?

The crux of this question lies in the individual’s passion for wine and desire to share this passion with the world. It’s about connecting cultures and bringing people together around the table, shattering borders, and uniting people over a glass of wine.

The U.S. has always been a melting pot of different cultures and ideas, and this diversity makes us great, not the inherent belief we developed in our greatness. Wine is meant to unite us in our differences and open a window into a world we may never have thought about. Stories of passion and perseverance, family, progress into the future, and reverence for the past can be found in a glass of wine, whether imported or homegrown. These ideas have never been more significant than now in a society where we are so connected to one another yet so incredibly distant.

Genuine importers, following in the footsteps of people like Kermitt Lynch, Martine Saunier, Terry Tiese, and others, suffer the legislative and administrative barbs and jabs of the unforgiving wine world to bring culture from across the globe to unite us in our humanity.

The End is Nigh?

Sadly, I must conclude this soliloquy by returning to what started this conversation: the looming threat of a 200% tariff on E.U. wines. Wine has always been an interconnected, international product, regardless of who made it and where. This diversity and cultural exchange has always been pivotal for wineries, importers, wine shops, and restaurants. This tariff can potentially destroy what took centuries to build and lies in something so much deeper than trade politics.

A Paso-Robles Sangiovese will never replace or imitate the heart and soul of vines that grow in Chianti Classico or the village of Montalcino.

A California “Champagne” ( it even hurts to put those words together) is not an alternative for the crayeres (chalk caves), where the Champenois developed their styles for centuries, no matter how well made.

 Placing exorbitant tariffs on European wine will not bring American wines into the limelight but will instead set events in motion that will damage the reputation of wine overall.

 And it will hurt.

It will hurt American businesses, especially small, family-owned businesses that struggle to survive on little more than a passion for wine and a belief in open cultural exchange.  

And all of this for one man’s hubris.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *