Wine Education

Varietal Exploration[Vol. 7]: Garnacha, The Misunderstood Genius

Written by Simone Popov · 6 min read >

Grenache, Garnacha, Garnatxa, Cannonau, Aragones,  Tocai Rosso ?

Tinta, Roja (or Gris), Blanca, Tintorera, Peluda?

There are many names, permutations, and even misnomers for this ancient grape, as often is the case with grapes of great viticultural significance, but what, in fact, is Grenache? Is it one of the greatest varieties in the world, a very pleasant but overall incomplete wine, a fruity easy-drinking quaff for the masses, an uninteresting pale red/rose often sold in bulk, or perhaps all the above? Setting aside my absolute love for the grape, I set off to answer these key questions to better understand and help others understand what I consider one of the misunderstood varietal-genius grapes of the wine world.

Origin of Contention

There is no doubt that Garnacha, the name I will use instead of the francophone one (except where necessary), is an ancient grape. The first mention of the grape was in 1513 under the moniker Aragones, implying origin in North-East Spain.  Yet at roughly the same time, in 1549, the varietal was also mentioned in Cagliari, on the island of Sardinia, under the ancient name Cannonat.  Since then, there has been a point of contention between the Italian Island and the Spanish Autonomous community over the grape’s origin. However, whereas Spain has all three color variations of Garnacha (Tinta, Roja, Blanca) as well as the Peluda mutation (hairy Garnacha), and Sardegna only the Tinta, it is widely accepted that Spain is the origin of the grape.

The Modern Age

While the debate over Garnacha’s origin remains contested, the grape has continued to spread. There are significant plantings of Garnacha in Spain, Grenache in Southern France, and Cannonau in Sardinia and small parts of Italy. Beyond these strongholds, it can be found throughout the Mediterranean and has spread across the Oceans to the U.S., Australia, South Africa, and beyond.

Yet with the variety’s widespread adoption, Garnacha lost its identity.  In Australia, where it was once the country’s favorite, it lost its dominance to more easily identifiable, characterful Syrah (of Shiraz, if you’re down-under). Because of its fruitiness and lack of deep color, Garnacha became the ideal base for some less-than-brilliant Rose/Rosado wines, and the grape still has an association for many people with the pink quaff.  And as the general wine appreciation has shifted to brighter, more racy styles of wines, Garnacha in general, with its tendency to lack in acid and build alcohol, has been lagging behind in the eyes of the sommelier community.

 Essence of Garnacha

What makes Garnacha particularly attractive to growers across many regions is its ability to thrive in relatively hot climates. The grape is early-budding but late-ripening, requiring a long, warm, and dry season. As alluded to earlier, the grape (and most of its mutations) tends to be low in acidity and develops a high level of sugar during ripening, which then leads to a high level of alcohol in the finished wine. Though the lack of acid and the pronounced alcohol are not necessarily desirable, Garnacha can express beautiful, often ripe aromas and flavors such as stewed strawberry, plum, dried herbs, licorice, blood orange, and others. This is where blending other grapes to help supplement and adjust the nature of a Garnacha-forward wine becomes crucial. Syrah can bring a firm backbone of tannins and enhance acidity, while Mourvèdre can add color, tannin, and more complexity.

Additionally, from a viticultural standpoint, Syrah is an ideal co-fermentation partner for Garnacha, as Syrah is a reductive grape (it must be allowed oxygen to prevent off-flavors) and Garnacha is oxidative. Together, the two allow for a more stable and less labor-intensive fermentation.

For those pale, fresh rosados, Carignan and/or Cinsault is added for the acidity they provide and the color that they, like Garnacha, lack during extraction. But this is not to say, by any means, that Garnacha cannot stand on its own. In some regions, the grape’s pure expression creates wines that stand alongside the world’s best.

Global Expressions of Garnacha [Tinta]

France

As noted earlier, Garnacha is often blended with other grapes to enhance its character and mitigate perceived flaws. This is particularly the case in most of the Southern Rhône Appellations, such as Côte du Rhône Villages and Gigondas, where blending is not only preferred but also required by appellation rules. But in Châteauneuf-du-Pape, where Grenache is allowed to stand on its own, it finds the most finesse in the sandy-soil wines of Château Rayas and a few other pioneers. 

In Tavel, across the Rhône, on the other side of Châteauneuf, producers make a savory, Grenache-rich rosé that is one of the best examples of Gastronomic rosé.

Further south in the Languedoc, Grenache leans deeper into its jammy notes and is still supplemented by Syrah, Mourvèdre, Carignan, and others.

Spain

In Spain, Garnacha is planted almost everywhere, to various degrees of success. The Rosados (particularly from Navarra) often make their way to supermarket shelves not only in bottle but sometimes even in can form but are not generally regarded as top expressions of Garnacha. In fact, that honor belongs to the brownish, schistous, nutrient-poor soils of Priorat DOQ and the high-elevation, granitic soils of Sierra de Gredos (without appellation, although many wineries label “Vinos de Madrid” or “Mentrida DO”).

Priorat

In Priorat DOQ and its surrounding Montsant DO, Garnacha is known for some of the richest and most powerful expressions, with poor soils limiting yields and the warm, dry climate allowing for full concentration and flavor development. Priorat has traditionally blended Garnacha with its partner-in-crime Cariñena (called Samso in the area and Carignan in France), to amplify acidity, but has also been blended non-traditionally with Syrah, Cabernet Sauvignon, and other international grapes. To me, the addition of Cariñena does take away some Grenache character, but any of the international grapes (even the complementary Syrah) completely obscures the beauty of Garnacha’s structure in Priorat.

Sierra de Gredos

Photo Cred: Wikipedia

Gredos is quite the opposite of Priorat, in both its blending ethos and style. Typically 100% Garnacha, Gredos wines are ethereal and light, expressing a broader range of Garnacha red fruit and floral notes uncommon to the riper versions. These wines have caused a few critics to dub them the “Spanish Burgundy”, due to the elegance and unique terroir expressions,  though I do still find that comparison imprecise and rather reductive.

Though the vineyards of Gredos hold great promise for many a sommelier, the Catalan vineyards are far more steeped in Garnacha history. It is in Catalunya that you find one of the most interesting, unique, and delicious Garnacha styles: Vi Rancio. On the surface, these wines are the furthest from cool: fully ripe Garnacha pushing 17% ABV, aged oxidatively in oak and typically blended year over year via solera, these wines represent tradition and Catalan heritage unlike any others.

Author’s Note: The Vi Rancio style is also prevalent in Roussillon, across the Pyrenees from Catalunya. Here, VDNs (Vins de Doux Naturels) of Banyuls are more often fortified, while Spanish ‘rancios’ traditionally aren’t.

Beyond

Due to its ubiquity, its quite challanging to generalise Garnacha outside of its two main countries. Sardegna in Italy tends to produce styles with a distinct ripeness. Most producers will either follow the single varietal approach, or use their Garnacha in a cuvee like they would in South of France. Australian GSMs are particularly apt for the richer Rhone style.

Variations- Mutations, Evolutions, Not Garnachas

Photo Cred: WeinPlus Lexicon

In previous examples, we looked specifically at the Tinta version of Garnacha, the grape simply called Grenache in French. But as we saw, there are more variances and mutations that deserve acknowledgment. Let’s start with the:

“Garnacha” Tintorera: NOT Garnacha

It is, in fact, a grape called Alicante Bouchet, a crossing of Garnacha with Petit Bouschet. This mislabeled grape was very popular with growers in Spain post-phylloxera, as it was incredibly vigorous and carried the “Teinturier” gene, which leads to pink flesh and deeper color in wines. The wines produced from this imposter Garnacha can be soft and fruity but generally lack complexity and character, unlike the best examples of actual Garnacha. Exceptions would include incredibly old vine plantings, such as those at Adega O Cabalin or Valdesil in Galicia.

Garnacha Peluda: Hairy Garnacha

Photo Cred: La Buena Vida

Similar to Garnacha, but with some fuzzy white hairs on the bottom of the leaves. The wines produced from this grape tend to be higher in acid and tannin than standard Garnacha. In Catalunya and Aragon, it was often tradition to blend Peluda and non-Peluda under the Garnacha label. Such labeling could confuse someone new to the variety, leading them to associate Garnacha with a deeper color and a far more intense, tannic character.

Garnacha Blanca

Jancis Robinson refers to the white mutation of Garnacha as “sometimes slightly blowsy”, a charming, if somewhat outdated, Britishism for a stout, thick-set figure. I partially agree, as this white counterpart of the Garnacha Tinta also suffers from its more famous twin’s lack of acidity and excess alcohol, which, when not managed, can create truly subpar “fat” wines. But at its best, when yields and ripeness levels are controlled, these wines can be exceptional, particularly in the Catalan Terra Alta DO and Priorat DOQ. And if not on its own, Garnacha Blanca is an excellent blending partner for a variety of Spanish white grapes, bringing the verticality that Garnacha severely lacks.

Garnacha Roja/ Grenache Gris

Here I use the French synonym, mainly because I have not had a Spanish Garnacha Roja (yet); however, some of my absolute favorite white wines from France are crafted from this grape in the region of Roussillon. Perhaps more attention should have been paid to Roussillon, as it is a bastion of high-quality Grenache in all its forms, but what particularly impressed me was the Gris (or Gris-Blanc blends) from this region. Wines from Grenache Gris, particularly those from Le Roc des Anges and Matassa, are racy, beautiful, incredibly complex, and some of the most exciting white wines from the South of France (or any region), and deserve great recognition and praise, though they are still under the radar of most wine lovers.

Garnacha, the Future of Wine?

It is quite challenging to summarize more than a few unique grapes from a variety of regions across Spain, France, Italy, and beyond, even if they do belong to the same Garnacha family. It presents the same issue to many sommeliers and wine professionals, who are unable to talk with confidence about Garnacha in the same way they can rattle off the 10 Cru of Beaujolais, the Premier Grand Cru Châteaux of Bordeaux, or the Grand Cru vineyards of Vosne-Romanee.

But at the same time, Garnacha is here to stay. It is the variety perfectly tailored to our current climatic predicament, better suited to many vineyards that, at the moment, are planted with Cabernet Sauvignon and even Pinot Noir in some places. The beauty of Garnacha is that it can truly tell the tale of its climate; it’s just that, in some cases, it isn’t the story wine lovers want to hear. But this is the same with Merlot, which was overplanted, suffered from a dip in cultural appreciation, and readjusted. So perhaps to answer the question asked at the beginning of the essay:

“Garnacha can be both incredible and average. Complex, and quaffable, powerful and elegant. It is precisely this dichotomy that makes the grape excellent, one of the most important varieties in the world, and a viticultural genius grape”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *